This exercise is great for demonstrating how so much of a song’s power and meaning come from how the music and lyrics work together (I may refer to lyrics as poetry and vice versa). Technically, it’s only a writing activity for music and poetry if you do both parts; however, even the first part alone is worth the doing. Both because of how well it demonstrates the point and because the results can be pretty funny.
The Power of Music and Poetry Combined
Like any class, this starts out with a demonstration. This particular demonstration can then be used to inspire writing. Here’s how it works.
- Pick two songs with very different moods. Preferably songs that you know by heart (lyric and melody). They can have similar topics or not.
- Sing the first song’s lyrics to the melody of the second song. You don’t have to do the whole song, but try to make it through a verse and/or chorus at least.
- Reverse it. Use the first song’s melody with the second song’s lyrics.
- Evaluate the result. If you can stop laughing or shuddering with horror (depending).
It’s not easy to do, is it? When you know a song well, you don’t know the lyrics and melody separately – they go together. The way they fit together is what makes it that song.
Changing the melody or lyrics of the songs can change their moods and meanings completely. Even when the words are exactly the same, so much of what influences their meaning changes. Such as
- Which words are emphasized (by holding them longer, larger intervals, etc.)
- The emotion behind the words (Or the one implied by the music anyway – look up the lyrics for “You Are My Sunshine” if you want an example of words and music that don’t really match.)
- Pauses (You would not believe how much the length and placement of pauses influences meaning!)
Those are really important in songs and in poetry.
A Writing Activity
This writing activity is a little like the poetry writing prompt for free verse – it involves writing the same meaning multiple times before arriving at the final wording. You can be writing a poem or song lyrics (honestly, the only real difference is the intent of the writer).
- Choose a topic.
- Brainstorm the characteristics of that subject that you want to emphasize. In other words, make a list.
- Pick a mood to try first.
- Write the poem for that mood. Word choice, meter, rhyme, and imagery are some of your best tools for influencing the mood of the poem.
- Set that poem aside.
- Pick a different mood. The bigger the difference, the better.
- Write a new poem for that mood. Use the same topic and characteristics you used for the other poem, but change the word choice, meter, rhyme scheme, etc. to change the mood.
- Compare the two.
That’s it. It’s great practice for learning techniques to create different moods with your poetry and especially for making sure that the mood enhances the meaning. For instance, that you didn’t get caught up in a meter that doesn’t fit what you were trying to write (easy to do). Or started rhyming too much or too little. Maybe you need to defy that rhyme or take away alliteration instead of adding it.
It all depends on what you’re trying to accomplish.
If you don’t feel like you mastered it immediately (who masters anything immediately?), do it again. And again. And again.
How many times will it take? I don’t know – you tell me.